30 November 2021
BOLD (Bulgarians Organising for Liberal Democracy) unites citizens who want Bulgaria to be a society with democratic governance and a pluralistic political system, where everyone’s fundamental rights and freedoms are protected, while laws, policies and practices are aimed at greater socioeconomic and environmental justice.
In the context of three successive parliamentary elections within eight months, difficulties to form a regular government and a declining voter turnout, the majority of Bulgarian citizens today expect the political parties elected to Parliament on November 14th to avoid self-serving partisan battles and form a government with a clear governance programme addressing the serious challenges facing Bulgarian society and Bulgarian democracy.
BOLD puts forward to the political parties and coalitions participating in the negotiations for the formation of the next regular government of Bulgaria eleven demands for the consolidation of democratic values in policies at legislative and executive levels. We expect to be heard, encouraged by politicians’ stated willingness to be open to civic participation in forging the future coalition agreement and governance programme.
- Preserving and strengthening Bulgaria’s European orientation. Policies or actions that would hinder Bulgaria’s full membership in the European Union and NATO should not be acceptable, nor should parties whose platforms include anti-European values be allowed to participate in the new government. It is necessary to intensify efforts to join the Eurozone and to transpose all EU directives into domestic law in a timely manner.
- Strengthening civic participation in governance. Civic participation is an essential component defining the quality of democracy. In Bulgaria, however, civic participation has many significant problems, some of which are: the lack of genuine empowerment and agency of citizens in relation to the constitution, even though the latter is a “social contract” between citizens; insufficient decentralisation and insufficiently strong local self-government; limited scope of the right to vote; lack of influential and effective instruments of civic control between elections; legislation that effectively blocks referendums; non-compliance with regulations regarding citizens’ initiatives (ZPUGDVMS) and a very weak right to carry out petitions (signals, suggestions); ineffective public consultations and deliberations, ineffective public councils, etc.; insufficient transparency and lack of proactive information from public sector bodies as a prerequisite and framework of citizen participation. It is necessary to overcome the perception of citizen participation as being limited to consultation, and improve mechanisms for citizen involvement in the drafting and adoption of legislation and policies at all stages of the political process. We therefore urge the future government to introduce a reform to ensure far more diverse and meaningful forms of citizen participation in all phases of the political process: problem formulation, official agenda setting, proposing solutions, debating and deliberating, decision-making, and monitoring of implementation.
- Strengthening the independence of the justice system from political interference and increasing its effectiveness in protecting citizens’ rights. The stated willingness of most political actors to reform the justice system should translate into a comprehensive and thorough approach, seeking a solution not only to issues around the mandate, responsibility and mechanisms for the removal of the Chief Prosecutor, but also addressing all other problems and imbalances in the structure and functioning of the justice system that undermine its independence and effectiveness. In addition to the standard online public consultations, the work on this issue should be organised in such a way as to ensure, through a variety of forms, in-depth professional and public discussions involving representatives of the judiciary, the academic community, human rights and other civil society organisations. We insist that the reform of the justice system should include direct access of individual citizens to constitutional justice, in order to improve the justiciability of rights and freedoms – an essential feature of the rule of law and a democratic society.
- Reforming media legislation and policies to ensure greater independence and freedom of the media:
Bulgaria is among the worst performing countries in the world in terms of media freedom. Measures need to be taken to strengthen the independence of public media management bodies so that the decisions they take do not favour any political power. Legal guarantees of transparency of media ownership and the origin of their funds should be strengthened, and a package of measures should be put in place to prevent media market concentration as well as the monopoly of distribution of the print media. Bulgaria can follow the example of measures in countries with very well-developed regulation in this area, such as Austria, Germany, Norway, etc. Such measures might include: limiting TV and radio broadcasting licences; limiting the proportion of shares that can be owned by a media service provider in another media service; limiting share ownership in related activities in the same segment of the media industry; limiting share ownership in other segments of the media industry; regulating audience share by introducing measures when an operator exceeds a certain audience level, etc.
- Measures to counter all forms of discrimination, including hate speech, and to improve respect for the rights of people from vulnerable groups and minorities.
Recent statements and actions of many politicians have allowed the Roma, who are systematically unequal in all areas of social life and who have waited in vain for effective integration policies, to be stigmatised as a major actor in vote-buying and as the culprits of many of the country’s crises. The Turkish minority, on the other hand, has incrementally come to be identified with corruption practiced by the Movement for Rights and Freedoms (DPS), and the voting rights of Bulgarian citizens living in the Republic of Turkey have been presented as the source of nothing but trouble for Bulgaria. These discourses must be opposed with utmost determination. Refugees, whose right to asylum has been cruelly trampled upon through xenophobic statements and actions contrary to international law, must no longer be seen as a threat to national security and be provided with the support that Bulgaria owes them as a signatory to the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees. Bulgaria needs to end its policy of non-admittance of refugees, honour its commitments to EU policies responding to migration pressure in the spirit of European solidarity, and actively participate in the ongoing debates on reforming European migration policy.
We draw attention to the fact that the idea of creating a National Guard proposed by parties involved in the negotiation process is directed against vulnerable groups and is highly inappropriate. It would not strengthen the state, the democratic institutions and the protection of human rights, but work in the exact opposite direction. Whereas this idea of a National Guard has been repeatedly put forward in the public domain in previous years, democratic civic opposition to it has so far prevailed. We insist that it should not be given the go-ahead this time either.
We assess the state of compliance with equal rights norms by the Bulgarian government as a matter of grave concern, and as violating numerous international treaties as well as Bulgarian law. We therefore urge the future government to adopt a comprehensive national equal rights strategy to counter sexism, racism, xenophobia, religious intolerance, homophobia and intolerance towards people with disabilities. We believe that, on the basis of internationally established principles and standards in this area and in consultation with civil society, the future government should:
- Perform a review of the effectiveness of the Protection from Discrimination Act and the work of the Commission for Protection from Discrimination;
- Introduce a bill amending the Penal Code to include sexual orientation and gender identity as qualifiers similar to race, nationality, ethnicity and religion in the offences against persons and property; update the legal definitions in the Penal Code of offences including domestic violence, rape, sexual harassment, psychological harassment, etc., in order to meet international standards, including a discriminatory element that reflects the fact that this type of violence disproportionately affects women; adopt the amendments to the Law on Protection from Domestic Violence, initiated and developed by the Ministry of Justice in early 2021 and supported by many civil society organisations and experts during their public discussion.
- Adopt national policies on equal rights for persons belonging to ethnic minorities, refugees, and persons with a different sexual orientation or gender identity – groups that are currently the most discriminated against.
- Respecting and guaranteeing children’s rights and adopting measures to support children and families, consistent with the principle that the child is a subject of rights and can only grow and develop their potential in a safe family environment. In the context of the current serious demographic crisis, policies in this area should be aimed at providing health care, including mental health care for children and young people; promoting early childhood development; quality education and support for building parental capacity to encourage positive and responsive parenting. The government should develop, and the National Assembly should adopt, a National Strategy for the Child in fulfilment of the obligation under the Child Protection Act.
- Legislative change to ensure that all people living in the country can obtain identity documents by eliminating the dependency between having an address registration and accessing the issuance of identity cards and other personal documents. In 2012, amendments were adopted to the Civil Registration Act, which made the requirement of documents proving ownership of residential property, or alternatively, the legal right to inhabit that property, a condition for registering one’s permanent address. An identity document, such as an identity card for Bulgarian citizens and a foreigner’s identity card for foreigners, is required in a huge number of situations relating to access to fundamental civil, political, economic and social rights. Those who are not in possession of such a document are in practice deprived of their rights to participate in social and political life and to carry out legally valid actions of any kind, as they cannot prove their identity. Such citizens do not exist in the legal universe of the country. They cannot exercise their rights to education and training, work, marriage, family life and inheritance, acquisition of property, or social and health insurance.
Due to the fact that a significant percentage of people of Roma ethnic origin in Bulgaria live in unregulated neighbourhoods and do not have ownership documents for their homes that in many cases had been built without the necessary construction licence, they are affected to a much greater extent by this problem. Many of them, including children aged 14-18, cannot obtain an identity document. According to various studies, including the new draft National Strategy for Roma Inclusion, there are no fewer than 75,000 (according to other estimates, over 100,000) citizens of Roma origin in the country who do not have identity documents because they cannot obtain a permanent residence certificate at their address. The problem affects not only Roma, but also other Bulgarian citizens, most of whom live below the poverty line. In view of the foregoing, we demand a legislative change that would facilitate as much as possible everyone’s access to identity documents.
- Ensuring access to effective and fair healthcare, both in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic and beyond. The pandemic has further highlighted the need for a reform of the health system to build its capacity to deal with emergencies. It is even more important to step up preventive health care, whose current ineffectiveness puts our country in the last place in the EU, both in terms of vaccination and the incidence of a number of lifestyle-related diseases. There is an urgent need for a large-scale communication campaign on vaccination against Covid-19, for which adequate budget funding should be allocated and local and international communication expertise sought. The campaign should prioritise messages to people who are at highest risk of death or severe illness if infected with SARS-CoV-2 variants, namely the elderly over 60 and people with certain pre-existing medical conditions (cardiovascular, pulmonary, oncological, etc.).
- Adopting measures to reduce social inequality and promote social inclusion. Bulgaria is a country with a high degree of social inequality, with a significant overlap between socioeconomic marginalisation and ethnic origin. The future government’s measures in this area should:
(a) be in line with the UN 2030 Sustainable Development Goals and the European Pillar of Social Rights;
(b) correct particularly acute cases of social injustice, including through reform of individual income policies;
(c) address the pay gap for men and women working in the same job;
(d) lead to the economic empowerment of long-term unemployed, young people not in employment, education or training, persons with disabilities and other categories of economically most vulnerable people;
(e) include an active policy for equal access to quality education, desegregation of so-called “Roma schools” in multi-ethnic settlements and ensure multicultural upbringing of children in the classroom;
(f) include active measures to improve healthcare for the Roma as currently they have a much lower life expectancy compared to non-Roma and health services for Roma are less available, less accessible, and of poorer quality compared to the rest of the population.
(g) to pursue much more vigorously the provision of accessible environments and inclusive design for persons with disabilities.
10. Unblocking the EU membership negotiations of the Republic of North Macedonia. Bulgaria’s policy towards the Republic of North Macedonia, while insisting on respect for the rights of persons with Bulgarian ethnic identity residing there, should also develop good neighbourly relations in a mutually beneficial, confidence-building way that secures our common European future. It should give a strong impetus to active cooperation activities in the fields of political, diplomatic and civil exchange, economy and the environment, science, education and culture, military-technical cooperation, media and information technology.
The discussion of historical questions, rather than dominating the approach to cross border communications as it has been the case to date, should be incorporated as one aspect of culture and education and implemented while ensuring contemporary historiographical approaches and pluralistic expertise of the invited participants. We therefore urge Bulgaria to give the green light for the start of the EU membership negotiations of the Republic of North Macedonia by setting specific, verifiable, realistic and time-bound conditions for the Republic of North Macedonia to implement in relation with the Treaty of Friendship, Good Neighbourly Relations and Cooperation, to serve as milestones in securing Bulgaria’s continued support during the long negotiation process ahead.
11. Preventing the appointment of persons with a record of human rights abuses to key leadership positions in the future government. It is important for us, citizens, that the standards of good governance based on democratic principles, rules, transparency and accountability are promoted through governance activities at all levels.The negotiating parties’ pledge is to move towards a qualitative change in the way public policies are made. However, past bad practices have convinced us that this goal cannot be achieved if the political personalities on whom it depends to implement meaningful reforms do not come with a proven record of democratic integrity in addition to professional competence. We are convinced that a new start in political life will not be made and that the rule of law will not prevail if the Cabinet includes ministers who have a record of human rights violations.
With respect:
BOLD (Bulgarians Organising for Liberal Democracy)
